Thursday, October 1, 2026

Album of the Year for 1973

 Behind Closed Doors (Charlie Rich)

Behind Closed Doors (Charlie Rich album) - Wikipedia

Behind Closed Doors, the biggest hit album for Charlie Rich, is a smooth blend of so-called “Countrypolitan” or “Nashville Sound” music, that mix of country and pop styles that allowed a lot of artists, including Rich, to cross over to mainstream success and exceptional popularity across genres. The two best songs are the ones that reached #1 on the Billboard Country Singles Chart: “Behind Closed Doors” and “The Most Beautiful Girl.” That second song also reached #1 on the Billboard Hot 100 chart for two weeks. I like “The Most Beautiful Girl” a lot, and it deservedly got attention from the record-buying public, but is there a sexier country song from that era than “Behind Closed Doors”? It’s about public behavior vs. private behavior and about how the singer’s lover clearly shows the, um, fullness of her love when they’re alone together. After all, “no one knows what goes on behind closed doors” except for the people who are intimately involved. This was one of Rich’s biggest hits during his so-called “Silver Fox” era. "The Most Beautiful Girl" is clearly about a man who’s caused a breakup: “I woke up this morning / Realized what I had done.” It winds up being one of the loveliest and saddest songs in country music with the singer begging everyone to tell his lover that he’s sorry. No wonder it was such a hit. "I Take It on Home" was the first single released from the album, and it’s an enjoyable tune about being faithful to someone even when you’re not always home. The temptation is there, but the singer is happy to return home to their loved one, who has also presumably been faithful too. Most of the songs are just two or three minutes long, little gems that represent a very prominent style of music from the first half of the 1970s, but some stand out. If you want an almost perfect example of how metaphor is used in country music, look no further than "I'm Not Going Hungry Anymore.” Why not? Because his lover’s love is all he needs to, um, satisfy his hunger. That’s “hungry” meaning the same thing as “thirsty” now, I guess. The album turned out to be quite the family project with four of its eleven songs being written by members of the Rich family. Charlie Rich wrote “Peace on You,” infusing it with a resonant gospel sensibility. His wife, Margaret Ann Rich, contributed two songs, “A Sunday Kind of Woman” and “Nothing in the World (To Do with Me).” Both of them are sort of the country equivalent of torch songs, with an especially nice twist in the second song. Even his son Allan, who was a teenager at the time, penned “You Never Really Wanted Me,” a nice song about lovers reuniting, a subject that must have been an intriguing one for such a young songwriter. Rich won the Grammy Award for Best Male Country Vocal Performance for the title song, beating such talents as Kris Kristofferson, Tom T. Hall, Johnny Russell, and Charley Pride, all of them singing what would become classic country songs. As you might expect, the album was a huge hit on the country charts, reaching #1, but it was also a big success on the Billboard Album Chart, reaching #8. It’s been certified quadruple platinum for more than four million copies sold. Interestingly, it was also chosen as the Album of the Year by both the Country Music Association and the Academy of Country Music, two groups that are not always in sync when it comes to their choices. That’s a pretty good sign of just how popular Rich was at the time.

Singles: “I Take It on Home” (#6 on the country singles charts); “Behind Closed Doors” (#15 on Hot 100 and #1 on the country charts); “The Most Beautiful Girl” (#1 on both the Hot 100 for two weeks, the country singles chart for three weeks, and the adult contemporary chart for three weeks, quite the hat trick)

Most Essential Track: “The Most Beautiful Girl” was the bigger hit, but I think “Behind Closed Doors” is the more influential song. It bears repeated listening, and it was chosen as both Single of the Year and Song of the Year by the CMA and the ACM. It was also chosen as Best Country Song at the Grammy Awards.

My Favorite Track: I would pick “Behind Closed Doors” here as well. It’s just such a great song and so… precise in its implications. I do enjoy the implications of “I’m Not Going Hungry,” but “Behind Closed Doors” is a more direct statement of the same subject.

 

The Divine Miss M (Bette Midler)

The Divine Miss M was Bette Midler’s debut studio album. The title refers to the stage persona she cultivated playing in gay bathhouses like the Continental Baths in New York City, and it’s a moniker that has stuck with her throughout her long career. Most of the songs on the album are actually from her act at the bathhouse, and one of the producers is her former piano accompanist, Barry Manilow. This LP features one of Midler’s greatest traits, the ability to revive a song that has been performed by other artists and reinterpret it and make it her own. You’ve probably heard Tanya Tucker’s and Helen Reddy’s wonderful takes on “Delta Dawn,” but Midler’s version is so unlike either of those and well worth the revisiting of its lyrics. Likewise, “Do You Wanna Dance” and “Superstar” have versions that most people are more familiar with, but you still need her take on them. She’s also a great musical archivist. For example, here she takes on John Prine’s emotionally resonant “Hello in There” and infuses it with a great deal of emotional intensity and vulnerability. The album was a success both critically and commercially, reaching #9 on the Billboard Top 200 Albums chart and being certified platinum for sales of more than a million copies. Four producers worked on the album: Manilow, Ahmet Ertigun (the famed Atlantic Records co-founder), Geoffrey Haslam, and Joel Dorn. They bring a jazz and pop music sensibility to the recordings. In addition to the nomination for Album of the Year, Midler won Best New Artist and was nominated for Best Female Pop Vocal Performance for “Boogie Woogie Bugle Boy.”

Single Releases: “Do You Wanna Dance” (#17 on the Billboard Hot 100 chart); “Boogie Woogie Bugle Boy” (#8); “Friends” (#40)

Most Essential Track: A tough choice given how many of these songs have been standards for Midler’s concerts… but most people would probably say “Boogie Woogie Bugle Boy,” given that it was the biggest hit single release. I might pick “Hello in There” just because I’m getting older and its lyrics have become more resonant with each passing year.

My Favorite Track: Another very tough choice… but I’d probably pick the version of “Friends” that ends the album. Yes, there are two versions of the song on the LP, each from different sessions. I prefer the one from Session 2, but both of them are gems despite being quite distinctive.

 

Innervisions (Stevie Wonder)

Innervisions - Wikipedia

Stevie Wonder wrote all of the songs on Innervisions, his 16th studio album, and he co-produced it with Malcolm Cecil and Robert Margouleff. It’s considered one of the masterpieces from his most productive period, the 1970s. The album reached #4 on the Billboard Top LPs & Tapes chart (now the Top 200) and #1 on the Soul Albums chart, and it was Wonder’s first of three albums to with the top honor from the Grammy Awards. “Too High” provides a funky start to the album; it’s very upbeat and quite energizing. The next song, “Visions,” immediately softens the mood, giving an ethereal change of pace. It’s the kind of song that would be playing in the background at a shop that sells crystals, and I don’t necessarily mean that in a bad way. “Livin’ for the City” really is the centerpiece of the album. It’s more than seven minutes of narrative, sounds of the city, dialog, and it attempts to depict a large landscape of what’s going on in the urban environments of the time. Wonder’s delivery replicates the frustrations of the people being described in the song. It’s just great and deservedly won the Grammy for Best R&B Song. “Golden Lady” is a smooth love song, the second best on the album after “All in Love is Fair.” The album really does have quite the range of musical styles and subjects and instruments. You can see that very clearly in the first single released from the album, “Higher Ground,” a soul/funk masterpiece about reincarnation and becoming better versions of ourselves. It was memorably covered by the Red Hot Chili Peppers in 1989, but the original is still the best. I find “Jesus Children of America” to be the most perplexing song on the album. It seems like it’s a spiritual meditation, but it doesn’t seem like it’s the most flattering portrait of religious faith, does it? And its tendency to keep looping back through the lyrics, while creating a unique sound, might be counterproductive to the message. If I have a second-favorite song on the album, it’s probably “Don’t You Worry ‘Bout a Thing,” such an upbeat message about remaining positive in the face of difficulty and the support others can give. In addition to its win for Album of the Year, Innervisions won the Grammy for Best Engineering, Non-Classical Recording, and it was inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame in 1999. It began a rather unprecedented run at the Grammy  Awards for Wonder, one of the most talented musicians of the modern era.

Singles: “Higher Ground” (reached #4 on the Billboard Hot 100); “Livin’ for the City” (#8); “Don’t You Worry ‘Bout a Thing” (#16); “He’s Misstra Know-It-All” (did not chart in the US but reached #10 in the UK)

Most Essential Track: “Livin’ for the City” takes the listener on quite the journey through its multiple narratives and its use of dialog and story.

My Favorite Track: I’m inclined to pick “All in Love Is Fair” because it’s such a beautiful song that was covered so memorably by Barbra Streisand, but I figure that might be too obvious. Wonder’s rendition of the song is quite lovely, though, and it’s one of his most romantic songs.

 

Killing Me Softly (Roberta Flack)

A person sitting at a piano

AI-generated content may be incorrect.

Killing Me Softly was the fourth solo studio album by the great Roberta Flack. It reportedly took 18 months to record before finally being released in August of 1973, and it was worth the amount of time given the quality and range of the songs it includes. The album became an early influence for what would become known as the “Quiet Storm” radio format that featured smooth, romantic, jazz-influenced R&B songs. (The trend would be named for a Smokey Robinson album of 1975.) The title song for Flack’s was deservedly a huge hit, and Flack also scored a second Top 40 hit with “Jesse,” but more about those two songs later. Appreciate the hint of gospel influence on the upbeat pop/soul of “No Tears (In the End)” and the jauntiness of the old-fashioned, almost vaudevillian “When You Smile.” Listen to the evocative piano playing by Flack herself on the quiet, gentle “I’m the Girl.” Flack was an accomplished pianist, but this track features her work at its peak emotional impact. The performance of “River” wouldn’t be out of place in a honkytonk or juke joint on a Saturday night or in a small country church with a powerful choir on Sunday morning. Interestingly, almost a quarter of the album’s running time of 41 minutes is devoted to a performance of Leonard Cohen’s “Suzanne.” Cohen’s song, which was been recorded many times by many different artists, presents a beautiful examination of interactions (romantic? platonic?) he had with the dancer Suzanne Verdal. Flack’s version features sweeping instrumental sections and keeps building with intensity as the song progresses. She also switches to improvisational jazz vocalizing for the second half of the song, and it just becomes stunningly mesmerizing. Killing Me Softly was the best-selling album of Flack’s long career, reaching #3 on the Billboard chart Top LPs and Tapes (now the Top 200 Albums) and #2 on the Soul LPs and Tapes. It was eventually certified double platinum for sales of more than 2 million copies. In addition to being nominated for Album of the Year, Flack received two Grammy Awards for her performance of “Killing Me Softly with His Song,” Record of the Year and Best Female Pop Vocal Performance. Her win for Record of the Year made her the first artist to receive that honor in two consecutive years. Only U2 and Billie Eilish have achieved the same distinction.

Single Releases: “Killing Me Softly with His Song” (#1 on the Billboard Hot 100 chart); “Jesse” (#30)

Most Essential Track: The title song, which would later be inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame, justifiably won Song of the Year and Record of the Year. It also has inspired a range of cover versions, most famously by the Fugees, who took Flack’s version into a new hip hop atmosphere. It’s a timeless and beautiful classic.

My Favorite Track: If I’m being honest, I have come to appreciate Flack’s rendition of Janis Ian’s “Jesse,” a quiet meditation on missing a loved one, more with each listening. It’s one of the quietest and most touching torch songs of that era. The person in the song is just wallowing in their misery from their lover’s absence, and it’s tough to listen to Flack’s tender voice deliver a line like “Jesse, I’m lonely, come home” without being overcome by emotion.

 

There Goes Rhymin’ Simon (Paul Simon)

There Goes Rhymin' Simon - The Paul Simon Official Site

Paul Simon’s third solo album, There Goes Rhymin’ Simon, features ten songs all written by Simon in a range of musical genres. It reached #2 on the Billboard Album Charts (behind George Harrison’s Living in the Material World – not a Madonna song lyric) and was certified platinum for sales of more than a million copies. “Kodachrome,” the first single and the first song on the album, is named for the brand of film that no one uses any longer because almost no one uses film at all. Naturally, there was a copyright dispute with Kodak and at least the fear of a copyright lawsuit, but they eventually came around and used it in their commercials. It has an upbeat tempo despite being about some dark thoughts: no girls could ever match “my sweet imagination” and “all the crap I learned in high school” are just a couple of odd examples. And why, exactly, would your Mama try to take your Kodachrome away? Is it because you’re not looking at the world clearly? Are you preferring to see it through the bright colors of a “sunny day”? As someone who has lived in apartments for a large portion of my life, I completely understand the sentiments in “One Man’s Ceiling Is Another Man’s Floor.” Crazy stuff happens in apartment buildings, and you know that something is going on even if you don’t want to know the details. I first heard “American Tune” during an anti-drug presentation in high school; this was many, many years before D.A.R.E., so we just watched weird films about how bad tripping on drugs was. The presenter, who happened to be the father of Mac McAnally, an award-winning singer-songwriter-musician, said it was one of his favorite songs about America. I wouldn’t describe it as the most optimistic song—perhaps it’s more of a gentle disenchantment with where the country was seemingly headed—and it was right after the reelection of President Nixon and while we were still dealing with the Vietnam War, so maybe “I wonder what went wrong / I can’t help it, I wonder what’s gone wrong” resonated even with a middle-aged man in rural Mississippi. “Tenderness” is not a sweet love song despite its title and the expectations that come it. If your complaint is “There’s no tenderness / beneath your honesty,” clearly this is not a pleasant conversation. If you want a more traditional love song, listen to “Something So Right,” which is about being happy with someone else. “Learn How to Fall” really is a song about having a growth mindset song released decades before the concept of growth mindsets really took off. We do sometimes fall or fail because “nobody stops and scrutinizes the plan,” including ourselves. “Loves Me Like a Rock” presents a story of a mother’s love being unconditional and lasting, and it features a bit of a gospel influence. The background vocals are by the great Dixie Hummingbirds, who won the Grammy for Best Soul Gospel Performance for their version of the same song and deservedly so. The album has a lot of delightful lyrics and vocal performances: “Take Me to the Mardi Gras” with its celebratory mood, “Was a Sunny Day” and its Caribbean feel, and “St. Judy’s Comet,” a sweet lullaby to a young son. In addition to the Album of the Year nomination, Simon was nominated for Best Pop Vocal Performance, Male, losing to Stevie Wonder, a trend that Simon himself joked about at a later Grammy Awards ceremony when he thanked Wonder for not releasing an album that year.

Singles: “Kodachrome” (reached #2 on the Billboard Hot 100); “Loves Me Like a Rock” (also reached #2); “American Tune” (#35); “Take Me to the Mardi Gras” and “Something So Right” (a double-sided single that did not chart in the U.S. but reached #7 in the United Kingdom); “St. Judy’s Comet” (did not chart in the U.S. but reached #9 in France)

Most Essential Track: I’d give “Loves Me Like a Rock” the slight edge over “Kodachrome” because it wound up having far more people covering it. It’s also a great song.

My Favorite Track: Someone’s personal history can certainly make a song a favorite, and so I’m going to pick “American Tune.” We had a student in my high school who duplicated it on numerous cassette tapes to share, and I wore out my copy, which was not of exceptional quality to begin with.

 

Grammy Winner: Innervisions was the first of Stevie Wonder’s three Album of the Year Awards.

My Choice: I would agree with the Grammy voters and think Wonder’s album is exceptional, but I certainly would have loved for Roberta Flack to have won the Grammy for this masterful album. Look at the strength of that lineup, though; all of these are truly classic albums.

Note: The best-selling albums of 1973 were all released in 1972 and stayed on the charts throughout 1973. In order, they were The World Is a Ghetto by War, Summer Breeze by Seals & Crofts, Talking Book by Stevie Wonder, No Secrets by Carly Simon, and the soundtrack to Lady Sings the Blues, which is technically a Diana Ross album. Sometimes, the Grammys are a bit behind the sales reports.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Record of the Year for 1978

One of the biggest dance hits of all time squared off against one of the most romantic ballads for the Grammy for Record of the Year for 197...