One of the biggest dance hits of all time squared off against one of the most romantic ballads for the Grammy for Record of the Year for 1978. Three other records that fit most comfortably in the easy listening/soft rock genre rounded out the field. All five sold lots of copies. Four were certified gold for having sold more than a million copies, and the other was certified platinum for having sold more than 2 million copies.
“Baker Street” by Gerry Rafferty
Gerry Rafferty’s “Baker Street” made it to #2 on the Billboard Hot 100 and stayed there for six weeks, unable to break the stranglehold that Andy Gibb’s “Shadow Dancing” had on the top spot. A troubled soul is at heart of “Baker Street,” someone who drinks to forget the tough day they’ve had, someone who comes home with dreams of another life, someone who keeps promising to turn their life around. They’re going to give up drinking and sleeping around, and they’re going to start a new, quieter life. The last stanza seems more hopeful than the rest of the song, frankly, with its notions of each day being a new day. He’s still going to be a “rolling stone,” after all. Rafferty, a former member/lead singer of the band Stealers Wheel (probably best known for “Stuck in the Middle with You”), was nominated for Best Pop Male Vocal Performance but lost to Barry Manilow’s “Copacabana (At the Copa).” Too bad there wasn’t a way to nominate the saxophone playing of Raphael Ravenscroft; it truly makes this record distinct. Rafferty’s vocals are pretty mellow overall, almost gentle given the subject matter, but each time a sax rift begins, “Baker Street” enters a new realm of spectacular musicianship. (Even the guitar solo near the end of the single version overshadows Rafferty’s smooth vocals.)
“Feels So Good” by Chuck Mangione
“Feels So Good” is Chuck Mangione’s only Top 10 Hit, having peaked at #4 on the Hot 100 (although it did spend a week at the top of the Adult Contemporary chart). The single version was released from his album of the same name, which features a version of the song that is almost ten minutes long and takes a while to build to the upbeat single record’s tempo. The single version has such an exuberance and delight, a dance-infused joy, really, that is quite infectious. It’s not often that a recording that features the flugelhorn either becomes a hit or gets nominated for Record of the Year. It’s also not often that an instrumental record makes the final cut for Record of the Year. Mangione recorded another version in 1982 that featured vocals by Don Porter. It’s rather silly, honestly, with its lyrics about someone depressed meeting someone who makes them “feel so good.” The tone of the version with vocals is so depressing by comparison. The original (the shorter version) has a great deal of energy and was very ubiquitous in 1978.
“Just the Way You Are” by Billy Joel
Billy Joel scored his first Top 10 hit and his first gold record with “Just the Way You Are.” The single reached #3 on the Hot 100 for two weeks and spent four weeks at #1 on the Adult Contemporary chart. The lyrics are a sweet testament to one person’s love for someone else, and they could easily come across as corny even if they are true. The notion that you’d stand by someone else no matter what, taking whatever comes their way whether good or bad, is a powerful one. It’s about a forever kind of love with someone that you accept without demanding that they change for you. Joel sings in a reflective mood here, and once again, a saxophone solo (this time by Phil Woods) punctuates the emotional impact of the singing. Bruno Mars released a song with the same title in 2010 that covers much the same territory, but the later record aims for something a bit more metaphorical with references to a woman’s eyes and lips and face. Interesting side note: Joel’s version was not nominated for Best Male Pop Vocal Performance, an award he would win the next year for his album 52nd Street.
“Stayin’ Alive” by Bee Gees
“Stayin’ Alive” is the only nominee for Record of the Year that was certified platinum. It stayed atop the Hot 100 for four weeks, and it was the second single from the enormously successful Saturday Night Fever soundtrack. The first single, “How Deep Is Your Love,” had won the Bee Gees the Grammy for Best Pop Vocal Performance by a Group for 1977, and they would win that award again for 1978 for the Saturday Night Fever soundtrack (which was the only real choice for Album of the Year in 1978). “Stayin’ Alive” would win the Bee Gees another Grammy for Best Arrangement for Voices. Anyone who’s watched the film’s opening that features this song will recall how perfectly it suits the film. John Travolta is walking with a can of paint while the lyrics discuss someone who’s had a rough life of many lows and highs. They’re trying to convince themselves that it’s going to turn out all right but fear that “life’s going nowhere.” I can’t truly understand all of the lyrics, though. I mean, what does “whether you’re a brother or whether you’re a mother” even mean? Of course, with a beat this good and harmonies this tight, does anyone even care what the lyrics say? It’s still shocking that none of the songs from Saturday Night Fever were nominated for the Academy Award for Best Original Song. At least, the Grammy voters noted how great this record was/is. “Stayin’ Alive,” in particular, is an almost perfect representation of the angst felt by the film’s title character, someone who uses the dance floor as an escape from the mundanity of ordinary existence.
“You Needed Me” by Anne Murray
“You
Needed Me” is Anne Murray’s only #1 hit, and it stayed at the top of the Hot
100 for just one week. Interestingly, it spent thirty-six weeks on the Adult
Contemporary chart but never reached the top position, and it only reached the
Top Five on the Country chart. And, yet, it is one of her most recognized songs
in a long career. The lyrics are about how important it is to have someone
there for you, giving you unconditional love. Of course, it can be quite corny,
but who doesn’t want to be needed by someone else? Who doesn’t want someone to
give you hope “when I was at the end”? Murray won the Grammy for Best Female
Pop Vocal Performance of 1978, beating such luminaries as Olivia Newton-John
(“Hopelessly Devoted to You” from Grease), Carly Simon (“You Belong to
Me”), Barbra Streisand (“You Don’t Bring Me Flowers,” her solo version), and
Donna Summer (“MacArthur Park,” which is really more of a dance record, but
there you go). Murray’s vocal performance uses her trademark low-key style of
singing to good effect. There are no histrionics here; the delivery is almost
matter-of-fact, an intriguing choice given the emotional weight of the lyrics.
Grammy Winner: “Just the Way You Are” by Billy Joel
My Choice: “Stayin’ Alive” is still making people dance and it brings a smile to your face despite the rather depressing lyrics, but you’d be hard pressed to deny the award to Joel’s tender expression of love. I’d agree (just barely) with the Grammy voters this time.
Note: “Baker Street” and “Feels So Good” didn’t make the list for Song of the Year. (Could an instrumental even be nominated for Song of the Year? Well, yes, they have been.) Joel’s “Just the Way You Are” won the Grammy for Song of the Year, so he won awards for his songwriting skills as well as his performance of the song. Joining it and “Stayin’ Alive” (written by Barry, Robin, and Maurice Gibb) and “You Needed Me” (composed by Randy Goodman) were “Three Times a Lady” and “You Don’t Bring Me Flowers.” The Commodores’ “Three Times a Lady,” written by the group’s lead singer, Lionel Richie, is really quite a beautiful song about trying to explain how much you love someone, almost trying to quantify one’s love. I never understood why they’re “at the end of our rainbow,” though. Is someone dying and the other person is trying to say how much they’ve meant? As for “You Don’t Bring Me Flowers,” this was the year the Neil Diamond (one of the song’s co-writers along with the legendary Marilyn and Alan Bergman) and Barbra Streisand recorded separate solo versions of the song. Streisand’s version garnered her a nomination for Best Female Pop Vocal Performance. “You Don’t Bring Me Flowers” would be nominated for Record of the Year for 1979 after Streisand and Diamond went into the studio to record their marvelous duet about a couple who are no longer in love the way that they used to be and how they feel about the changes in their lives now.
P.S. The top five best-selling
singles of 1978 on the Billboard charts, in order, were “Shadow Dancing” by
Andy Gibb, “Night Fever” by the Bee Gees, “You Light Up My Life” by Debby
Boone, “Stayin’ Alive” by the Bee Gees, and “Kiss You All Over” by Exile. Two
songs by the Bee Gees, and another one by their young brother Andy, all of them
produced by the Brothers Gibb—that’s quite a feat. Another notable achievement
is that four of the five top-selling singles dominated the number one position
on the Hot 100 for twenty-three weeks of 1978, almost half of the year just for
those four songs (with an additional ten weeks carried over from 1977 for one
song). “Shadow Dancing” was the third consecutive #1 record for Andy
Gibb, and it spent seven weeks atop the Hot 100. Gibb co-wrote the song with
his brothers, who are better known as the members of the Bee Gees, and it
became the biggest selling single of his far-too-brief career. It’s
a love song about how much one person needs the other person: “And in a world
of people, there’s only you and I / There ain’t nothing come between us in the
end.” However, the other person doesn’t seem to be on board or maybe they
aren’t even aware of the feelings that aren’t being reciprocated; “How can I
hold you when you ain’t even mine” sums up the pain of unrequited love quite
well. Speaking of Gibb’s brothers, the Bee Gees reached #1 with their third
single from the Saturday Night Fever, the appropriately
titled “Night Fever,” and stayed there for eight weeks. It was their
third of six consecutive #1 singles and one of the songs that still can bring
people to the dance floor. The Saturday Night Fever soundtrack
was huge, selling more than 45 million copies and generating several Top 10
hits, including four number ones. “Night Fever” describes the overpowering
desire to dance, to be a part of the rhythm that the world has. It’s also about
the joy of dancing with the mysterious woman of the song, this “sweet city
woman” who is “controlling my mind and my soul.” She helps the main character
make it through the night and face another day, very much the theme of the film
in which it appears. Debby Boone’s “You Light Up My Life” was nominated
for Record of the Year for 1977, and the song was a co-winner of the Song of
the Year Grammy for 1977 as well. It just sold so many copies that it wound up
being a top hit in 1978 as well. In fact, it was so big a hit that it
ranks as #11 on the top singles on the Billboard charts for 1958-2018. It will,
of course, be discussed in more detail in the post about the Record of the Year
for 1977. Exile’s “Kiss You All Over” spent four weeks at #1,
making it the biggest hit of the group’s career. Honestly, it’s pretty graphic
for 1978, with lots of sexual imagery throughout the song. Ultimately, the main
person in the song wants to show how much they love the other person, and what
more obvious and/or direct way to do that than with physical intimacy? As the
song suggests, “You can see it in my eyes / I can feel it in your touch / You
don’t have to say a thing / just let me show how much.” I, of course, heard the
song when it was initially released, but I must have been quite a naïve
15-year-old not to have understood the implications of the song’s title,
especially when the lyrics keep adding “and over again.” I certainly hope I’ve
learned a few things since then.
No comments:
Post a Comment